"A GOOD EDITOR is someone who CARES A LITTLE LESS about the AUTHOR'S NEEDS than the READER'S."
—Dene October
Preparing to Publish
So, you’ve hired an editor… now what?
Welcome back to another episode of, “What to Expect from the Editing Process.” I’ll be your host today, ready to answer your most pressing questions about what it’s really like sitting in the editor’s chair with hands well moisturized in case you need something to hold on to. It’s an exciting – albeit, anxiety-inducing – time in every author’s writing journey, and one that holds a lot of unknowns, at least the first time. But fret not my little wordsmiths – I’m here to walk you through exactly what you can expect after you hire an editor for your manuscript.
The Editing Process
The editing process can be a gruelling one, but it can also be a lot of fun if you let it. When you hand off the brainchild you’ve poured countless hours into knowing it will return to you drenched in red, you set your ego aside and embrace the learning experience. Yes, the purpose of editing is to polish your manuscript and help you to bring the absolute best out of what you have created. But if you fully engage with the process and take your time sifting through your editor’s suggestions, thinking critically about why they’ve made each one, you’ll begin to see your work in a new light. Your story will be better for it, but you as a writer, as an artist developing your skills and mastering your craft, will be better for it as well.
That’s something to be excited about! Don’t let the intensity of the process intimidate you. Your editor is there for you. They have your best interests at heart and want nothing more than to see you and your story succeed. After all, the majority of editors depend on repeat clientele, which means your success equates to their success. I promise, everybody – even the Stephen Kings and Neil Gaimans of the world – get their manuscripts back covered in little red marks. Turn yourself over to the process, let go of any fear or embarrassment you might feel at the prospect of criticism, and ride the wave, my friend. Editing is a judgment-free activity. Enjoy it!
Working with an Editor
The Initial Assessment
During your hunt for the perfect editor, you will likely request a few sample edits from a few different people.
From the editor’s perspective, this is as much an opportunity for us to assess your work as it is for you to assess ours. You might think editors, and especially freelancers like myself, simply accept every manuscript that comes their way. That is not – and should not – be the case for a variety of ethical reasons. I can only speak for myself, so here are a few examples of why I might “turn down” a manuscript, or point a potential client in another direction:
- The type of edit the author is requesting is not the type of edit that I believe the manuscript requires. I cannot ethically provide copy edits if I know there are glaring plot issues left unresolved. It’s a disservice to the writer and potentially to my own reputation should they decide to self-publish.
- I am inexperienced or unqualified to work with the genre or age group. I have little interest in historical fiction, for example, and therefore read very little of it, so I would not provide sufficient value to a historical fiction writer seeking editing.
- The author has values or beliefs that translate into themes in their writing and are starkly different from my own. That is not to say I would feel uncomfortable about exploring another person’s values, but if I do not understand them or firmly disagree with them, I would not be very helpful in representing them.
- The work is AI-generated. This should be a given, but I will not touch work that a human did not create. It’s incredibly rare that this issue arises, but you’d be surprised how many people try to pass off AI work as their own. I’ll let you in on a little secret though – we can always tell.
The thing about editing as a career is that there are no such things as “gravy projects.” Every manuscript is unique and requires something a little different from the editing process. Not only that, but every manuscript is representative of somebody’s dream. If I do my job poorly, cut corners, or make unethical exceptions knowing full well that I am not the right editor for the job, I might be effectively crushing the manuscript’s chance at publication – especially if the author is new to the editing process and blindly trusting that I know what’s best. The bottom line is that one paycheque is simply not worth an unhappy customer who will, rightfully so, go and tell all of their writer friends what a terrible experience they had. It would be a disservice to us both.
I say all of this to reassure you that if you were happy with the sample edit, and your editor was happy with the sample edit, then you can trust that that level of care and quality will continue. They would not have accepted the project if they did not believe they could do your work justice.
If you’re interested in learning more about sample edits, click here. Otherwise, let’s proceed with the assumption that, if you’re reading this, you’re hiring an editor for the first time. I’ll start at the beginning, using my own process as an example.
Working with an Editor
The First Read
Once you’ve signed a contract and sent in your deposit, the first thing I would do is read through your manuscript in its entirety. During this initial read, I will make notes about any developmental issues I spotted, common mistakes I need to keep an eye out for, stylistic choices I would like to either discuss or adhere to, etc.. I may have questions about you or your characters’ intentions at this point. Anything that I need to clarify before I get into the nitty gritty of it, I will do so at this time.
I try not to edit at all during this first read. I may correct obvious spelling or punctuation errors, but for the most part, the purpose of this read is to form an organic first impression of your story and your style as a reader before I put on my editing cap.
Working with an Editor
The Second Read
It’s during the second read when the editing magic happens. Depending on the style of edit, your editor will sift through your piece line by line, word by word, making notes and leaving suggestions to improve structure, style, and pacing using “Track Changes”.
Correcting errors is a big part of this, of course, but the important thing is polishing your words until they shine – bringing out the best in what you’ve written.
Keep in mind that all your editors suggestions are just that – suggestions. I highly recommend you consider each and every one, but at the end of the day, it’s your story and your name is going on the cover. Final say on all revisions is yours.
Working with an Editor
The Third Read
Not every editor does a third pass of a manuscript, but I personally like to do a quick one to check my own work. I’m human too, which means I’m also capable of making mistakes. I might return to particularly complex passages to ensure I made the right choices in terms of the suggestions I made. I will check over my comments to ensure they’re worded in a way that is clear and concise, but also compassionate.
I will confirm that none of the suggestions I made are likely to create other errors during your revisions. And, in the process of doing this, I will complete the editorial letter – the detailed analysis of your story.
Working with an Editor
Delivery
Once the edit is complete and the editorial letter is written, your editor will deliver both to you. In my experience, authors will usually have some clarifying questions or other comments that they would like to discuss before the project is fully complete.
Different editors will handle this in different ways, but with my clients, I am happy to go back and forth via email until they are satisfied that they’ve gotten everything they need from me.
Some authors prefer to have this conversation over the phone or via zoom, which is welcome too. Only when we have concluded these discussions will I send out a final invoice.
Additional Rounds
Once you have received your edited manuscript along with the editorial letter, you are free to begin your revisions. Again, the next steps vary depending on the editor you work with, but I am happy to give the manuscript one last read once your revisions are complete to check for any leftover errors or additional errors created during revisions. If you would like to proceed with an additional round of edits (for example, a line edit following a developmental edit), ask your editor about potential discounts. Many, including myself, will offer a lower rate for additional rounds of editing as they are already familiar with the piece.
Keep in mind that once an editor has read through a manuscript multiple times, it may become more difficult to look at it objectively.
For this reason, I suggest you hire a different editor for your copy edits or proofreading if you’ve already used the same editor for developmental and line editing. It’s not an insult or a question of their skill if you decide you would like a fresh set of eyes on your manuscript – in fact, it’s encouraged to avoid human error.
The editing process can seem overwhelming, but don’t be discouraged! Once you find an editor you trust, you can rest assured that they will do everything in their power to bring your manuscript up to publishable quality. It’s completely normal to bristle at some of the comments or suggestions you receive – we can all be sensitive to criticism, especially in our creative endeavors – but remember that it’s in your editor’s best interest to have your best interests at heart. Every suggestion they make is purposeful. So, even when you instinctively want to reject an opinion or perspective, give it a fair chance and really consider it. At the end of the day, whether or not you accept their changes is up to you.
If you made it to the end of this article, thank you! I hope you found it helpful. If you have any questions at all about the editing process, please do not hesitate to reach out or leave a comment below. Happy writing!